Showing posts with label story. Show all posts
Showing posts with label story. Show all posts

Friday, May 30, 2008

Parshat B’midbar 5768: Story as Transformer

I want to talk about story.

This week, we begin the book of Numbers, B’midbar in Hebrew. It starts on a very boring note: census data. Parshat B’midbar is seemingly not the most exiting stuff in the world. The book B'midbar will contain many stories. Indeed most of the book is story.

B’midbar was on my mind about three minutes after takeoff from the Airport in Eliat headed for Ben Gurion Airport. The sandy desert under us was creating strong thermals which translated into very strong turbulence. We diverted west to go around that turbulence, then headed back east over the Israeli and Jordanian evaporation ponds that are killing the Dead sea, then turned west once again to fly back over the Jordan, over Jericho to places that will be important in later history: Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. Whether inadvertently or not, the plane followed a serpentine route out my window that wasn’t far off from the route we read of in the Book of Numbers that starts this week. What will take weeks for us to read in the synagogue and forty years to accomplish in B’midbar took thirty five minutes.

Some of that route I traveled on the ground only days before, on my way to Petra. According to the locals, somewhere around Petra is mount Hor where Aaron died. Not far away is the town of Wadi Mousa, in Arabic the Valley of Moses. This according to local legend is the Place, where the princes dig their own wells for the people or even possibly where Moses struck the rock. While most biblical scholars have problems with this legend, Indeed Petra was the capital of the Nabatean Empire based on its plentiful natural springs, which made it an Oasis in an otherwise inhospitable wilderness. Jordanian Route 53 which we took to Petra might be a close approximation to the original route around the Edomites territory (Numbers 21). In a comfy, air conditioned bus I saw much of the route into the land of Israel.

I’m very glad I wasn’t walking this. B’midbar means in the wilderness, and this is a very inhospitable place. At places it is the desert of swirling sand dunes, but more often there is are small tufts of grass-like plants spaced far apart between large peaks and rock outcroppings all blasted by wind and sand into strange, melted patterns. Bedouins still live in Southern Jordan and often one will see in this monochromatic landscape a thin black line of a Bedouin tent.
To take this way into the land would have been a character builder. And I think it did build a lot of character into the story of B’midbar. While the English and Latin names reflect the census at this week’s and the beginning of next week’s portion, the Hebrew is far more descriptive with the words in the wilderness.

Judaism breaks down the types of writing in the Torah and later works into two types: Halakah and Aggadah. Halakah is law. Aggadah is everything else, but for a medium for this everything is usually story. One such Aggadic passage in the Talmud

R. Abbahu and R. Hiyya b. Abba once came to a place; R. Abbahu expounded Aggada8 and R. Hiyya b. Abba expounded legal lore. All the people left R. Hiyya b. Abba and went to hear R. Abbahu, so that the former was upset. [R. Abbahu] said to him: ‘I will give you a parable. To what is the matter like? To two men, one of whom was selling precious stones and the other various kinds of small ware. To whom will the people hurry? Is it not to the seller of various kinds of small ware?’[Sotah 40a]

Story telling is attractive useful and not very expensive, and thus its appeal. The story that will happen in B’midbar is attractive, with many twists and turns to the plot. But is is extremely useful to understand how to use all that halakah. There is a general theme of transforming form one kind of people to another. The Israelites left Egypt with a slave mentality, one that was a continual part of their world view. Their continual complaining about things is primarily about how things are not done for them. A slave make no decisions on his own, not even what to eat or when. In some ways this is a blessing. No slave ever has to wonder where their next meal comes from. They were completely dependent on their masters for everything.

By the end of Numbers the people are far different. Able to dig their own wells without divine intervention, they are an impressive military force, capable of defeating national armies. Instead of the timid people of the beginning of Numbers, they are to be feared. The life in the wilderness forged these people over 40 years into something powerful.

This is the primarily Aggadic book of Torah, where we learn that very important lesson. God is not going to make a miracle for everything we want. God may not even answer every prayer directly. Often miracles happen because we do the right thing to make them happen. Right mind and right action is just as important as divine intervention. One can rely on magic wells, or one can pick up a shovel and start digging around a suspicious number of trees grouped together. At the end of the day, the guy with the shovel is far less likely to be thirsty.

There are many transformation stories, many of them having a journey from one place to another as their theme. In modernity, there is Tolkien’s works for one example. Ancient stories like those of Odysseus or Aneas have similar themes. The person who starts the journey is not the same who finishes. Often, they are a better person at the end than when they began. While Moses is a main character, in many ways the Israelites themselves introduced by the thousands in this portion are the protagonists. This is a story of transforming these people:it is thier journey, not Moses’. As we learn in the prophetic literature, it wasn’t a completely successful nor permanent transformation, its something that requires constant attention.

Transformations are something I think a lot about as I’m in this transition period of my life. The enthusiastic grad student I was, so saturated with information led to a vast creative output in term s of this column. Six months after I finished my classes I’m feeling as dry as that wilderness the Israelites crossed. If not for two hours every Wednesday evening I’d have nothing at all inspiring me. For the last tow months I’ve written some of the least inspired columsn ever, if I wrote at all. I’ve seriously thought of dropping this column and even dropping my kosher rules and Shabbat prohibitions. My jewishness seems to have evaporated. Spending two weeks in the land hasn’t helped. Not even standing before the Kotel seems to have helped.

Maybe the wall did help. Last week, I mentioned half of what was in that piece of paper I put in the wall, and what that experience at the wall might mean for that second half. I think much of what I prayed was not about God granting me something as much as my learning the skills and courage to do it myself. Like I said last week, it's all staring me in the face. Prayer and connection to God provides something bigger than miracles – it provides a power to realize what you want and do something about it. Things become internally driven, by one’s Nefesh not externally driven like a taskmaster. We see this so clearly in Joshua and Caleb, the two spies who saw so clearly. If the people really wanted to up into the land, it was simply a matter of doing it and believing God was there to help.
I don’t know how things will go from here. I’m going to find way to inspire myself, one way or the other. As B’midbar might be saying, inspiration comes from the inside not the outside. As we go through the journey from Sinai to Mount Nebo, let’s find out together.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Parshat B’midbar 5767: In the Word,In the Story

Numbers 1:1-4:20

I want to talk about story.

This week, we begin the book of Numbers, B’midbar in Hebrew. It starts on a very boring note: census data. Parshat B’midbar is seemingly not the most exiting stuff in the world. The book B'midbar will contain many stories. Indeed most of the book is story.

Funny thing is, looking at the census data, it too is story. Once you being to look at the all this information you begin to see things. People’s names in particular.

7. From Judah: Nahshon the son of Amminadab. [1:7]

3. And on the east side toward the rising of the sun shall they of the standard of the camp of Judah camp their armies; and Nahshon, the son of Amminadab, shall be captain of the sons of Judah. [2:3]

Stories can be put together from many places. So we read of Nahshon back in Exodus

23. And Aaron took him Elisheba, daughter of Amminadab, sister of Nahshon, to wife; and she bore him Nadab, and Abihu, Eleazar, and Ithamar. (Ex. 6:23)

Nahshon is Aaron’s brother-in law. If we read a later text we find:

20. And Amminadab fathered Nahshon, and Nahshon fathered Salmon, 21. And Salmon fathered Boaz, and Boaz fathered Obed, 22. And Obed fathered Jesse, and Jesse fathered David. [Ruth 4:20-21]

Nahshon is the Grandfather of Boaz, who will marry Ruth. Ruth and Boaz in turn will be the great grandparents of King David. In the book of Ruth, we also find that Nahshon was descended from Tamar and Judah.

Names lead us down the path of stories. Nahshon is only mentioned nine times in the entire biblical text. He is not a very big character himself. Yet he can be connected to just about every major figure in the bible. Stories are meant to be embellished, and indeed Nahshon’s story has one particular embellishment.

R. Judah b. R. Il'ai expounded: When Israel stood by the Red Sea the tribes stood contending with each other, one saying, ' I will go in first,’ and the other saying, ' I will go in first.’ Thereupon Nahshon leapt into the waves of the sea and waded in. [Numbers Rabbah 8:4, Sota 37a]

The rabbis couldn’t resist adding the story of Nahshon most people remember. He was the first into the drink, even before it split. He didn’t talk, he just acted, and it was his act that caused the miracle according to some stories. If you knew of Nahshon you probably didn’t know he was a grieving uncle when Nadab and Abihu died. But you did know the powerful lesson, one driving all of Judaism, that it is our actions that are paramount.

One story that I repeat far too often lately is the one of the Hasidic Rabbi Leib. Rabbi Leib went to study with the Great Maggid not to learn Torah, but to learn how the Maggid of Mezhirech ties his bootlaces. To know the deeds of sages in even the little acts of everyday life and to tell stories has a powerful effect. We might have explicit rules but we also need to have something else to get us to do those rules. Story, aggadah, is that thing. We in Judaism do not believe in enforcement. Indeed the verb root for enforcing a rule is the same word for oppression. Instead we look to a different way, we model the behavior of our best and brightest, and we communicate that behavior through story.

As one of the greatest models for much of Modern Jewish behavior, The Baal Shem Tov believed when one tells stories in praise of the tzaddikim, it is though he were engaged in something as powerful as Mystical study. Stories, unlike law, tend to stick to us, because we have the experience that the rest of the world has. There is something concrete, and something emotional about Nahshon’s story, which is so different than merely stating a principle of “deeds, not words.” Nahshon entering into the Red Sea for me brings back images of being afraid to be the first to dive into the camp swimming pool. The fear is there. It is a very real place and time in my memory. Your vision of the event like Nahshon’s may be different. Yet, I believe that most everyone had a time and place they felt like the Israelites at the Red Sea, whether they did what Nahshon did or what the Israelites did there.

Story is summarized by my tagline, “It is a matter of Torah and I am required to learn.” [Ber 62a] If tying shoelaces is not enough, R. Akiba and his students telling stories of the toilet habits on one’s teachers in these stories on folio 62a of Tractate Brachot crosses the line past the absurd. We learn something incredibly important in such absurdity however. Our bodies are creations of God, everything done with them can be done in holiness and intention. I can make the statement or tell the story. The story is what is remembered and understood.

B’midbar is a collection of such stories set in the wilderness, the chronicle of the journey from Sinai to being at the shores of the Jordan, ready to enter the land of Israel. We meet many people besides our main characters of Moses and Aaron. We will meet pagan magicians, talking donkeys, rebellious relatives, slanderous sisters, irritated father in laws, a guy who works on Shabbat and his brilliant daughters. We get Satan’s first appearance in the biblical text, and a consortium of bad guys. People will whine, argue, lie, get sick and many will die. In all of these stories we will also see a bunch of whiny slaves turn into an unstoppable fighting force, only to be stopped by an application of social psychology. By the end, we find a people who are responsible enough to begin a new journey and a new story, the story of living in the land.

While we do not live in the wilderness, sometimes the events in our lives make us feel that way, in the next few weeks we get to revisit stories which help in those times. We get the emotional relief that we are not the first to see an unknown land, be it a new job or school, and feel like grasshoppers compared to the inhabitants at first glance. At the same time we are told by Caleb not to fear for we can do this thing, merely because we can. God is with us.

Abraham Joshua Heschel decried the over-emphasis on Halakah, the law, over Aggadah, the stories where we get our motivations, ethics and theology to follow the Halakah. They need to be a polarity, not one or the other but a balance. As we enter into the wilderness with the stories of the Israelites, lets’ look for the beautiful gems of story that can improve our live by telling them and living them. Maybe we will become stories too.